Home / Crypto Security / Arthur Hayes ‘Flattered’ as Coinbase Defends Stock Perpetual Futures in US Court

Arthur Hayes ‘Flattered’ as Coinbase Defends Stock Perpetual Futures in US Court

Arthur Hayes, the co-founder of cryptocurrency derivatives giant BitMEX, has admitted he feels “flattered” by Coinbase’s recent decision to back the Commodity Futures Trading Commission (CFTC) in a high-stakes US legal battle concerning stock perpetual futures.

The ongoing courtroom showdown highlights a major evolution in how digital asset-style financial products are moving into traditional equities markets. What was once viewed by American regulators as an aggressive, unauthorized frontier of financial engineering is now being robustly defended by some of the most prominent, regulated names in the mainstream crypto industry.

“When we launched the perpetual swap at BitMEX in 2016, Washington’s reaction was less than warm,” Hayes told Cointelegraph, reflecting on the tumultuous early days of the innovative derivative product. “Ten years later, Coinbase is in federal court defending the right to offer them on US stocks. I’m flattered. Imitation is the sincerest form of regulation.”

The legal dispute centers around a legal brief submitted on Monday by Coinbase alongside five other industry entities. The coalition of companies strongly opposed a push by an industry alliance to block trading in perpetual futures tied to individual corporate stocks. The presiding federal court formally accepted the brief on Tuesday, escalating a battle that could fundamentally reshape the regulatory boundaries of modern trading products.

The lawsuit itself was brought forward by the Capital Markets Alliance Association (CMAA). The association argues strenuously that these newly introduced perpetual contracts should be classified and regulated as security-based swaps. Under US financial regulations, security-based swaps are subject to significantly tighter restrictions, particularly regarding retail investor participation and oversight.

During his tenure as the CEO of BitMEX, Hayes spearheaded the launch of the Bitcoin perpetual swap. The financial instrument revolutionized the cryptocurrency derivatives market by allowing traders to maintain leveraged positions on Bitcoin without having to worry about a fixed expiration date or the operational friction of rolling over contracts. This single product design quickly became a foundational cornerstone of global crypto trading volume, eventually inspiring traditional financial technology firms and digital asset exchanges to explore similar mechanics for other asset classes.

SEC Weighs In on Stock Perpetuals

Complicating the courtroom battle further, the US Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) reportedly submitted a proposed court brief on Monday. The agency weighed in by opposing the alliance’s emergency request to temporarily halt trading in the disputed stock perpetual contracts.

However, the SEC’s stance remains nuanced and cautious. The regulatory body stated that it was actively reviewing the specific rules established by exchanges for listing these contracts. The brief deliberately left open the question of whether the SEC might eventually set those rules aside, as well as whether the controversial products ultimately qualify as security futures or security-based swaps under existing statutory definitions.

In a subsequent court filing submitted on Tuesday, the CMAA doubled down on its criticisms. The group argued that the CFTC had approved the contracts without providing an adequate explanation for its administrative decision or addressing deep-seated, unresolved regulatory questions that cut across agency jurisdictions.

To underscore the urgency of its claims, the alliance pointed to substantial early market traction. The group cited approximately $375 million in reported 24-hour notional trading volume generated by Kalshi’s stock perpetuals shortly after their initial launch. According to the CMAA, these figures demonstrate that the new products are already actively diverting significant business and liquidity away from traditional, established stock markets.

Stock Perpetuals’ Lack of Expiry Is at Issue

At the core of the legal debate is the defining characteristic of stock perpetuals: their lack of an expiration date. These contracts allow retail and institutional speculators to take positions on individual share prices without ever owning the underlying physical equities. Unlike traditional futures contracts, which compel settlement or rollover on a designated future date, perpetuals can theoretically be held indefinitely, sustained by periodic funding payments designed to tether the contract price to the underlying spot market.

The dispute reached an early procedural milestone on November 3. US District Judge Valerie Caproni denied the alliance’s request for a temporary restraining order, ruling that the group had failed to demonstrate that it would suffer immediate and irreparable harm without judicial intervention. Nevertheless, Judge Caproni acknowledged that the alliance demonstrated a strong likelihood of success on its underlying legal claim that the CFTC may have exceeded its statutory authority in approving the products.

Wojciech Kaszycki, a strategy adviser to BTCS SA, noted that the absence of a fixed expiration or delivery date introduces complex legal hurdles when attempting to fit perpetual contracts neatly into statutory definitions of futures.

Kaszycki told Cointelegraph that the central question of the case revolves around whether these instruments constitute a legitimate “sale for future delivery.” At the same time, he issued a stern warning regarding the broader ramifications of a potential ruling against the CFTC. According to Kaszycki, judicial hostility toward the product in the United States will not eliminate demand; instead, it risks driving trading volume away from regulated venues and straight into the waiting arms of offshore and decentralized platforms.

“The product doesn’t die; it just changes address,” he cautioned.

Tagged: