Major industry heavyweights, including cryptocurrency exchange Coinbase, prediction market platform Kalshi, and four other prominent financial and digital asset entities, have formally asked a federal court to accept an amicus curiae brief supporting the United States Commodity Futures Trading Commission (CFTC). The legal intervention comes amid a high-stakes federal lawsuit centered on the regulatory oversight of perpetual futures contracts tied to individual United States stocks.
According to a proposed amicus brief shared publicly by Coinbase legal representative Molly Abraham, the coalition of supporting companies also features Payward, the parent company of cryptocurrency exchange Kraken; institutional trading firms DRW Holdings and Jump Trading; and prominent crypto investment company Paradigm Operations. Together, these firms represent a powerful cross-section of modern market infrastructure, arguing before the court that single-stock perpetual futures clearly fall under existing United States futures laws and should be permitted to operate under the CFTC’s regulatory framework.
The coordinated legal filing arrives just days after a federal judge issued a preliminary assessment indicating that the CFTC likely exceeded its statutory authority when it greenlit the trading of single-stock perpetuals as security futures. This ongoing legal battle carries profound implications for the domestic financial landscape, as it could ultimately determine whether United States-regulated exchanges are legally permitted to offer retail traders innovative derivative contracts that track individual equities without a fixed expiration date.
Why Stock Perps Face Intense Regulatory Scrutiny
The controversy began to unfold publicly on November 3, when the CFTC announced a major policy shift, declaring that single-stock perpetual futures, commonly referred to as stock perps, could begin trading on US-regulated exchanges for the very first time. This regulatory nod opened the door for domestic platforms to introduce products that have long been popular in offshore cryptocurrency and derivative markets, allowing participants to gain exposure to equity price movements with high capital efficiency.
However, the introduction of these novel financial instruments immediately triggered aggressive pushback from traditional market participants. The Capital Markets Alliance Association (CMAA)—a newly formed trade and advocacy group representing traditional financial market participants, whose influential members include major market institutions such as Cboe and Citadel Securities—filed a lawsuit against the CFTC in federal court. The association’s legal challenge directly targets the agency’s authority, arguing that the CFTC overstepped its jurisdictional boundaries by allowing the controversial contracts to trade without proper legislative backing.
To understand the core of the dispute, it is necessary to examine the unique mechanics of the financial instruments in question. Stock perpetual futures allow traders to speculate on the price movements of individual public companies without requiring them to purchase or hold the underlying shares. Unlike traditional futures contracts, which have a fixed expiration date that forces positions to settle or roll over, perpetual futures can be held indefinitely, sustained by periodic funding payments between long and short positions to anchor the contract price to the underlying spot market value.
The central disagreement in the lawsuit revolves around how these contracts should be legally classified and regulated. The CMAA argues that because these derivative contracts lack a fixed expiration date, they do not legally qualify as security futures. Instead, the trade group contends they should be properly regulated as security-based swaps—a specific category of equity-linked derivatives primarily overseen by the Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC). Security-based swaps are subject to a much stricter regulatory regime, including significantly tighter restrictions and compliance burdens that heavily limit retail trading access.
Conversely, the six prominent companies backing the CFTC in the new amicus brief strongly disagree with this interpretation. They argue that a fixed expiration date is fundamentally not a statutory requirement for a contract to qualify as a security future. Under their reading of the law, security futures—which are subject to joint oversight by both the CFTC and the SEC—can legally encompass perpetual structures, meaning the CFTC acted well within its established mandate when it approved the products for trading on regulated domestic exchanges.
Judge Questions CFTC Authority But Declines to Halt Trading
The legal battle reached an initial milestone shortly after the CMAA filed its complaint, when US District Judge Valerie Caproni issued an evaluation suggesting that the plaintiff was likely to succeed in its core claim. Judge Caproni noted that the CFTC appeared to have exceeded its statutory authority by permitting single-stock perpetuals to trade as security futures under the current rules.
In her preliminary assessment, the judge indicated that the contracts in question appeared to function more similarly to swaps rather than traditional security futures. This judicial observation cast an immediate shadow of doubt over the regulatory agency’s legal interpretation and its authority to unilaterally expand the scope of exchange-traded equity derivatives without explicit congressional action or inter-agency alignment.
Despite expressing skepticism regarding the agency’s legal standing, Judge Caproni ultimately denied the CMAA’s request for a temporary restraining order. The judge ruled that the trade group had failed to demonstrate the standard of imminent, irreparable harm required to justify halting ongoing market operations before a full trial on the merits can take place.
By denying the temporary restraining order while allowing the lawsuit to proceed, the court left the CFTC’s trading approvals intact for the time being. This leaves the nascent market for stock perpetual futures operating on regulated US exchanges, even as the underlying legal framework faces severe judicial scrutiny. As the litigation moves forward, the CMAA is scheduled to file its official reply to the CFTC’s opposition memorandum regarding a preliminary injunction, setting the stage for the next critical phase in a dispute that will shape the future of retail derivatives trading in the United States.






